STENHOUSEMUIR: GRAEME ARMSTRONG
By Paul Forsyth
For a club so rarely acquainted with silverware, Stenhousemuir have had their share of greats. Like striker Robert Taylor, whose 32-goal tally in season 1925/26 remains a record. Or midfielder Ross Meechan, a stalwart of the team who won the club’s first league title in 2024 and are now sampling the giddy heights of the Championship.
Indeed, the current crop of players are as high up the league ladder as Stenny have ever been, but it isn’t perhaps the most eye-catching side in their 142-year history. That honour goes to the giant-killing, trophy-lifting class of 1995.
If striker Miller Mathieson was the towering focal point of Terry Christie’s celebrated line-up 31 years ago, Graeme Armstrong was its most remarkable story, a left-sided midfielder/full-back/centre-half whose astonishing longevity is unparalleled in Scottish football history.
Armstrong joined Stenhousemuir at the age of 36 and spent the next eight years playing for them. His 268 appearances in that time contributed to a career total of 910 Scottish League games that is, by a distance, the most ever recorded by a player in Scotland. When cup competitions are accounted for, Armstrong has played over 1,000 games in senior football.
Those stats include a substitute showing for Alloa at the age of 44 and a six-season stretch in which he didn’t miss a single minute of a single game.
Stenhousemuir stalwart Graeme Armstrong receives a trophy marking his 1,000th appearance in 1999
The Edinburgh lad made his league debut for Stirling Albion in 1975, had six years there, three at Berwick Rangers and nearly a decade at Meadowbank Thistle before the latter’s manager, Christie, moved to Stenhousemuir and took Armstrong with him.
Armstrong could not have imagined that some of his best memories were still to come. He made his 1,000th senior appearance when Stenhousemuir played Rangers at Ibrox in 1999, an occasion on which he was afforded a guard of honour and a standing ovation.
In 1995, he was part of Christie’s starting line-up for three of the club’s most famous games.
First, the part-timers knocked Premier Division St Johnstone out of the Scottish Cup in a third-round replay. Adrian Sprott scored twice in a 4-0 thrashing that utterly humiliated Paul Sturrock’s side.
In the fourth round, Stenhousemuir beat Aberdeen 2-0 thanks to a second-half double by Tommy Steele. Traumatised Dons boss Roy Aitken visited the home dressing-room afterwards to congratulate them on being responsible for the worst result in his club’s history.
Later that year, on Guy Fawkes Day no less, Stenny were still on fire. In the Challenge Cup final at McDiarmid Park, they secured their first national trophy by beating Dundee United on penalties.
Around 2,000 of their fans were there to see Lloyd Haddow convert the decisive spot kick. As one Ochilview wag later put it: ‘Remember, remember the fifth of November, Armstrong, Haddow and Sprott.’
They were heady times for Christie, his famous duffel coat and the indefatigable Armstrong, who was captain and assistant manager on that memorable afternoon in Perth.
Armstrong’s Stenhousemuir career also included a 15-month stint as their manager. He guided them to promotion, was sacked in April 2000 and later enjoyed a trophy-laden six-year spell in charge of junior side Newtongrange Star.
And through it all, the great irony was that Armstrong’s marathon of a career was complemented by another in sprinting. In the 100m, he was a serious proposition, contending for prizes at the Highland Games, the New Year Sprint and in veteran races well into his 60s.
In 2005, Armstrong was voted Stenhousemuir’s all-time cult hero by viewers of BBC’s Football Focus. You can understand why.
STIRLING ALBION: MATT McPHEE
By Alan Hendry
He made a record 505 appearances, but all of the things that made Matt McPhee such a special player for Stirling Albion were evident in just one snapshot of his storied time at the club.
Needing to avoid defeat against Stranraer at Stair Park to claim the Second Division crown in April 1977, McPhee came up trumps with the goal that uncorked the champagne for Alex Smith’s swashbuckling side. Using his trademark speed and anticipation, McPhee latched onto a through ball before composing himself to skilfully slot home the title-winning goal.
It is only fitting that Albion’s greatest ever player was on hand to score one of the most important goals in the club’s history.
Club record goalscorer Billy Steele – another candidate to be the Binos’ GOAT – and Mickey Lawson may have been poster boys of Albion’s golden era of the 1970s but there is no doubting McPhee was the heartbeat of that team.
It is fitting that McPhee was the first player to make the club’s hall of fame when it was launched in 2024. Steele, stalwart goalkeeper of the 1980s/90s Mark McGeown and legendary manager John Brogan were also inducted.
Stirling Albion legend Matt McPhee
A dynamic winger with speed, skill and creativity… but also tough enough to withstand the rigours of a long season, McPhee was everything and more to Stirling Albion.
In fact, former manager Smith could scarcely believe he wasn’t prised away to greater things. The Binos faithful were the beneficiaries of that glaring oversight, and their reward was to enjoy the delights of watching McPhee between 1967 and 1981.
McPhee passed away aged 79 in 2026 and Smith paid tribute to the Albion legend.
‘Matty was at the heart of Stirling Albion during what was probably the greatest era in the club’s history,’ said Smith.
‘His ability, pace and goalscoring would have taken him to the next level of the game, but it was probably only that shyness as a person that stopped him.’
None who witnessed it will forget McPhee’s solo goal in a 1-0 win over Dunfermline in 1980. With Albion down to ten men, the mercurial midfielder took matters into his own hands, using his blistering pace to beat several Pars players before blasting the ball into the net.
He would often save his best performances for the big occasion, hitting a stunning free-kick past Celtic goalkeeper Pat Bonner in front of a 40,000 crowd at Parkhead in August 1980. A legendary moment from an iconic player.
Incredibly, the goal gave Albion a 2-0 aggregate lead after a 1-0 first leg win in the League Cup tie, but their giant-killing dream was shattered by a late Tommy Burns goal, before they eventually lost out 6-2 after extra time.
‘Stirling Albion has had a lot of great players with that selfless mentality,’ confirmed Smith. ‘But Matt McPhee has never been surpassed in his stature at the club. I’m privileged to have worked with him.’
STRANRAER: JOHN ‘LOLLY’ McCUTCHEON
By Alan Hendry
Perhaps it is only fitting that we would have to delve deep into the history books to unearth the greatest ever player of Scotland’s third oldest club.
Famous for his fierce, swerving cannonball shots, descriptions of John ‘Lolly’ McCutcheon would make you think you are reading about a real life Hotshot Hamish.
His scoring record also wouldn’t look out of place in Roy of the Rovers or Tiger, with 238 goals in 239 games in the late 1940s and 1950s making him the club’s record scorer by the proverbial country mile – ahead of 1970s hero Jim Campbell (136 goals).
Reports of McCutcheon’s prowess tell of an unorthodox, unpredictable forward who would flummox goalkeepers with his shooting power and ability to make the heavy leather ball change direction midflight, maybe with the help of the salty air blowing in off Loch Ryan.
McCutcheon seemed to raise his game against bigger teams, making it his personal mission to ensure that any big names would leave Stair Park feeling a little shorter in stature than when they arrived. In one 3-3 draw with Rangers ‘A’, visiting goalkeeper George Niven was certainly made to feel uncomfortable whenever the ball fell to McCutcheon, with the local hero helping himself to two goals.
Stranraer goalscoring legend John ‘Lolly’ McCutcheon
Scotland and Rangers goalkeeper Bobby Brown also found McCutcheon a tricky opponent in a later game.
Nobody compares to Lolly in Scotland’s south-western footballing outpost but, in more recent times, new legends have been born in the shape of Jim McCabe, David Graham, Michael Moore and Craig Malcolm.
Striker Malcolm enjoyed three spells at the club between 2010 and 2023, hitting the back of the net 106 times in blue to become only the third player in the club’s history to surpass a century of goals.
McCabe’s Stranraer story is also worth re-telling. With his long hair and generous paunch, McCabe looked more like a seventies rock star (Stair Park Way to Heaven?) than a footballer when he pitched up from Motherwell in 1975.
His performances on the pitch, in tandem with strike partner Derek Frye, are the stuff of legend in Stranraer.
While a suspect attitude and disregard for training might have explained why McCabe was turning out at Stair Park rather than Celtic Park or Ibrox, there is no doubt the mercurial forward could turn on the style when the mood took him.
One goal in a 5-1 hammering of Falkirk was the stuff of fantasy. Receiving the ball on the halfway line, McCabe dribbled past five despairing opponents, before rounding the goalkeeper. With the Bairns begging to be put out of their misery, there was one last indignity to come, McCabe dropping to his knees to insouciantly head the ball over the goalline.
THE SPARTANS: BLAIR HENDERSON
By Alan Hendry
To be the greatest ever player at one club should be enough for even the hungriest footballer. To be The Goat at TWO clubs can only be considered greedy.
Spartans – and Edinburgh City – legend Blair Henderson has always been a player with a big appetite for goals and his ‘huge footprint’ is writ large over the Pilton club’s short spell in the SPFL.
Who scored the decisive penalty for the Edinburgh side against Albion Rovers in the pyramid play-off final? Henderson of course.
Who scored their first competitive goal as an SPFL side, in the giant-killing of Dundee United in the League Cup in 2023? The very same man.
When it comes to Spartans, all roads lead to the tall striker, who claimed 106 goals in just 190 appearances from 2021 to 2025.
Long-serving manager Dougie Samuel paid tribute to Henderson when the striker departed the club.
Spartans goal machine Blair Henderson (left) with team-mate James Craigen
‘Some players leave their mark, leave a huge footprint when they move on from a football club. Some players can say that they helped a club to reach new heights. Hendo leaves Spartans having achieved and done just that. I feel very lucky to have worked with and got to know Blair, he’s been a real joy to manage. ‘
Henderson’s garage must be brimful of match balls after he racked up no less than six hat-tricks in his time at Spartans, albeit four of those came in Lowland League fixtures.
The tall target man may be peerless at the Vanloq Community Stadium but there could be a threat on the horizon to his GOAT status in Pilton.
Midfielder Jamie Dishington still has a few chapters to write in his own Spartans story but fans already worship the ground that he walks on.
The midfielder has made over 200 appearances since graduating from their academy and etched his name into folklore by scoring their first ever goal in League Two, in a 1-1 draw against Clyde in August 2023. Despite playing in midfield or on the wing, Dishington has an eye for goal having netted 77 times for Spartans, with 12 of those coming in the SPFL era.
Like Spartans themselves, Dishington took to SPFL football like a duck to water and scored three goals in their first four games.
He scored equalising goals against Clyde and then Dumbarton, seemingly taking the club’s unbeaten start to the campaign as his personal responsibility.
Let’s leave the last word to Henderson though.
‘In the Summer of 2021, Dougie Samuel sold me the dream of promotion and a place where I would become something, I bought it and we delivered!’ he said in 2025.
‘Thank you to everyone who made me feel so welcome and to every single person who has contributed to an amazing success story which definitely isn’t finished yet.’
Henderson is now applying his gossamer scoring touch at Linlithgow Rose but the streets of Pilton – and Meadowbank – won’t forget the mark he made on a club forging their nascent path on a journey of discovery.
Agree or disagree? Get in touch at [email protected] and let us know what you think
